| Platinum | Buon Padre Pizza |
| Gold | Zesty Zzeek's Pizza and Wings |
| Silver | Barro's Pizza |
| Silver | Brooklyn V's Pizza |
| Bronze | Crust Simply Italian Chandler |
| Top Pick | Bella Gusto Urban Pizzeria |
| Top Pick | Organ Stop Pizza |
| Top Pick | Rush St. Pizza |
| Top Pick | Stone & Vine Urban Italian |
| Top Pick | Venezia's New York Style Pizzeria |